Can I say something? I’m going to say it! Some romance novels set girls’ and women’s expectations to an unrealistic standard of men in a comparable way to how porn sets boys’ and men’s expectations of women to an unrealistic standard.
We all know that porn exists. We all know it is predominantly for the cisgender, heterosexual male gaze. And we all know the cisgender, heterosexual male gaze is misogynistic. Blonde hair, curvy body, small waist, submissive and excitable. An “idealized” woman for men that wet themselves with lotion. Perfect.
Some women watch porn. But the porn industry is not geared toward women. You know what is? The romance genre. More than 75% of readers of the romance genre is read by women, and roughly speaking, about 80% of porn is watched by men. Both women and men have ways to explore their sexuality; however, porn is much more problematic. But that’s a conversation for a different day.

What I’d like to discuss is the phrase: “A man written by a woman”. This is used to describe the male love interests in romance books written by women. They often have emotional intelligence, empathy and respect towards women, and are able to be a vulnerable, three-dimensional character. This is often what heterosexual women are looking for in a potential partner which is by no means high standards. It should be the bare minimum.
The type of man written by a woman I am curious about is the billionaire, the bad boy, the boy next door, the engineer that somehow is above six feet tall and has abs and is vegan just like her! No hate, no shade; I love Ali Hazelwood. I think her books are fun and I enjoy her more recent female characters a great deal. And she, amongst other authors, writes to a female fantasy. But is it a fantasy? Or is it something we are trying to manifest?
I don’t think it is wrong to write male characters that respect women, because anything less than that in a book or in reality should not be tolerated. But should we be writing these idealized forms of men without giving them flaws that make them human? Should we be teaching girls that go to these books for sexual exploration in a safe setting that a man should be rich with thick biceps and can make you come in the first sexual experience you guys have together?
I’m honestly not sure. I’m of the opinion that people should read whatever they want as long as it is not harming them or anyone else in any way. But has romance gone too far? This trope has always existed: the strong man saving the damsel in distress, it just changes with in time. Think of Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austin all the way to The Off Campus series by Elle Kennedy.
However, an argument I also understand is that these books are being written because women crave men that respect and love women. These books are being written because our society lacks men that have the emotional intelligence to be in a proper partnership with a woman. Are women going in search of love or good sex from books?
These books have become a safe space for girls and women to interact with the type of man they want. Is this a bad thing? I don’t think so. Just like I don’t think consensual and legal porn is necessarily bad. Everyone deserves to explore their sexuality in safe, healthy ways. I don’t believe this situation is black and white. I think there are nuances to be explored; for example: Are men written by women continuing to cage men in the idea that they must provide and must protect in order to be seen as a man? The same way that porn perpetuates the submissive stereotype of women. Are these romance novels continuing the burden of toxic masculinity?
I am not defending men. I am not defending their disrespect and the patriarchy ingrained in society. I’m just curious what romance novels are teaching girls and women. I thought I would see if you are too.

I find this really interesting especially knowing the type of books my best friend reads. She is big into mafia romance which often take patriarchal norms to the extreme. As you said, they portray kind, respectful men, but very much within the patriarchal norms of being a provider or savior. It is as you said, very nuanced though, because that is what some people seek in a partner, and you don’t want to deprive them of media representation, but you also don’t want to idealize this for everyone.