Wicker (2026): A Wicker Man Argument on Women’s Literature

Unless you’ve been living under a rock—or you’re pure of heart—you’ve probably heard of Wicker (2026). And if you’re like me, when the first official trailer came out on July 30th, 2026, your entire FYP on TikTok was flooded with clips, ads, and discussions over the movie.

Screenshot by me

The film starring Olivia Colman and Alexander Skarsgård is an adaptation of a short story called The Wicker Husband by Ursula Wills-Jones, following a lonely fisherwoman who asks the local basketmaker to weave her a husband out of wicker. Like the villagers in the movie, people online erupted, all too eager to share their own opinions about Skarsgård’s wood. However, the idea of a wicker man has a meaning that goes deeper than shown in the trailer and written in the short story.

It’s a wicker man argument about women’s literature.

TikTok by @bambistjames on August 3rd, 2026

Now, what do I (and the TikTok above that set me on this path) mean by that?

A wicker man argument is an extension of the more common straw man fallacy. Rather than misrepresenting an opponent’s specific point to make it easier to attack, a wicker man argument describes a much larger, systemic misrepresentation where an entire book, framework, or ideology is falsely constructed and evaluated based on what is missing from it, rather than what is actually inside it.

Now, what does that have to do with this narrative?

I’m going to explain how Wicker (2026) exposes and subverts this fallacy in three distinct ways:

(mild spoiler alert)

1. Critiquing by “Relevant Absence”

So, in rhetorical theory, a wicker man argument attacks a text for failing to include topics it never intended to cover. In Wicker, the protagonist (the Fisherwoman) lives happily outside the village’s rigid, institutionalized marriage structures. She catches her fish, runs her business, and is completely immune to the village’s archaic, oppressive marriage rituals. However, the community cannot comprehend a woman who is self-sufficient and immune to their gender roles.

The villagers construct a wicker man argument around her life. They frame her entire existence around a perceived “absence” —the lack of a human husband—and judge her as lonely, miserable, and incomplete, rendering her actual day-to-day happiness entirely invisible. By convincing themselves that her life is an incomplete tragedy, they protect their own fragile societal structure. If they were to admit that she is perfectly happy alone, it would expose their own rigid marriage systems as unnecessary and oppressive.

When she finally orders a husband made of wicker, she delivers the ultimate punchline to their fallacy.

“Here, damn” – Fisherwoman (probably)

2. The Fabricated “Problem” of Female Pleasure

When the Fisherwoman bypasses their society entirely and commissions a literal husband woven from wicker (who turns out to be devoted, emotionally soulful, and sexually spectacular), the village completely changes their tactical attack. Instead of accepting her happiness, the villagers build a massive, fabricated narrative about her.

Before the wicker husband arrives, the village men hold a complete monopoly on value. They believe they are the only source of security, status, and pleasure available to women. When a literal basket completely outclasses them domestically, emotionally, and sexually, their fragile authority crumbles.

This is exactly like the historic panic of the male-dominated publishing establishment when women authors began writing explicitly about female desire and domestic fulfillment (such as early scandals surrounding Kate Chapin’s The Awakening or Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre). When a female writer proves she can articulate a richer, more profound internal world without centering or flattering the traditional male protagonist, it shatters the monopoly male critics held over what constitutes “great literature.” The men in the village—and the critics in history—don’t critique the quality of the creation; they panic over their own sudden obsolescence.

kalimba and book on blanket
Photo by Furkan Elveren on Pexels.com

3. Litmus Test of the Outrage Machine

The real-world cultural reaction to the 2026 Wicker trailer perfectly illustrates a wicker man argument. When the trailer dropped, it sparked immediate discourse. Some critics and internet commentators immediately began generating bad-faith arguments, claiming the premise “objectified men” or “painted all single women as desperately lonely”.

These critiques completely ignored the text’s actual nature as a comedic, darkly humorous adult fairy tale meant to satirize patriarchal marriage tropes. Critics built a hollow, problematic effigy of the film to burn in public forums, perfectly executing a wicker man argument by evaluating the work based on a fabricated political agenda rather than engaging with its actual, satirical contents.

Screenshot by me

By literally putting a beautifully crafted, highly competent “wicker man” at the center of a story about female autonomy, Wills-Jones exposes how society would rather fight an entirely fabricated, hollow version of female independence than confront the reality that women are perfectly capable of defining satisfaction on their own terms.

One thought on “Wicker (2026): A Wicker Man Argument on Women’s Literature”

Leave a Reply