Is PC Culture Really “Destroying America”?

In the past couple of months it seems that PC Culture has been under attack by various media outlets and Presidential candidates. Politically correct  or “PC,” according to Merriam-Webster, is “agreeing with the idea that people should be careful to not use language or behave in a way that could offend a particular group of people.” Sounds like a pretty normal and reasonable request, right?
Apparently, for some people, PC culture is considered a way that progress is being “impeded” and has even been described as destroying America and it’s various institutions. Ben Carson is one republican Presidential candidate who has stated that PC culture is a way in which “[the left] frighten(s) people and get(s) people to shut up,” according to a Conservative news article.
What I don’t seem to understand however, is why exactly PC culture is so bad. Here’s some things people have said against PC culture.

  1. They’re just words. I have freedom of speech.
    While we often like to believe that our words mean nothing, they actually can have a huge impact on certain aspects of a person’s life. As my fellow blogger, FyAwayWithMe, discusses, Microaggressions can have a huge impact on the way that a person sees themselves, or others based off of identities. If someone uses the word “retarded”, for example, to describe a situation that they find displeasing, then this can actually have a huge impact on the feelings of  someone with disabilities because it gives them the idea that they may also be displeasing. Also, while we are given “Freedom of Speech” in our constitution, that doesn’t mean that we should exercise this right by acting in hurtful ways towards others. So just remember, just because you may think “it’s just a word”, to someone it can really hurt.

  2. I’m just kidding. Stop taking it so seriously.
     When we speak, we are just giving presence to the feelings that evade our conscious thoughts. Our lives are a constant flow of feelings in reaction to the world around us. These feelings turn in to speech which ultimately turns in to action. With this action, speech is a way that we inform each other of how we think, feel, and treat others. Thus, the way that we speak is often extremely intentional and a serious matter. 
  3. PC people are mean/rude/yell at me so I don’t need to respect them or their values
    Many people claim that a huge reason that PC culture fails is because of the way that PC people react when others use incorrect language. We can see many examples of this opinion in the media, including the new Season Premiere of South Park. In this episode the school gets a new principle named PC Principle who tends to act in violence and anger when others use offensive language. Despite this example this tends to be largely untrue. In my personal experience, people who embrace the PC culture often are interested more in the education of those who may not know about various identities, rather than shaming for said lack of knowledge. Because of this, I feel that this argument often falters.

Honestly, I think that being PC just makes sense. Why would any human ever want to speak in a way that they know would cause physical, emotional, and psychological harm to another? I think that PC culture is not destroying America, but pushing it forward.


3 thoughts on “Is PC Culture Really “Destroying America”?

  1. Very interesting read. I feel like this is a topic we don’t touch on very often. Unfortunately, there are many people out there who choose to ignore PC comments and be inconsiderate to the feelings of others.


  2. Thanks for writing this! During Thanksgiving, one of the unwanted conversations that came up from a conservative member of my family was if JMU had “PC zones where you couldn’t talk about anything.” The concern was nicely dismissed by my brother who said, “I think we’re all just trying to be as respectful as we can to each other.” That was a well-put comment, I think, and I’m glad he said it. (because I just got more wine). Great post!


  3. People have a lot of backlash when it comes to PC culture, especially recently.
    However I do agree with the fact that it is something that is important. Language is the center of our society, and when we realize the importance of inclusive language the better off we will be.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s