Bro status: a position bestowed only upon the worthy. A moniker given to the female that has successfully infiltrated the male camp. But, what does it mean to become a bro? I know when my roommates gave me the title that it’s supposed to be a compliment, but it’s hard to get past the slight insult. It feels like my gender is being erased, I just want to say, “Thanks, I think, but you know I’m still a girl, right?”
So, what exactly gets you to the “Bro” level? Did I get it because I talk about sex? Am I less than a woman if I talk about it openly and honestly? Is it because I curse like a sailor? Is it because I am assertive? Or rarely wear makeup? Is it just that my “masculine” tendencies overshadow my “feminine” ones? Is this what makes me a “Bro”?

Behind the deeming of “Bro” is the hidden idea that I was not as worthy before I had the name. With this title I have been raised from the muck of womanhood, and can now be accepted by and partake in the gentlemen adventures around me. I am expected to be a wing man and yet, give them the female perspective. I am supposed to be a “Bro”, an erasure of my gender, but I am also expected to be a representative of all females. It is a conundrum that I cannot help but think is an intrinsic part of male privilege. The dominance of men enables them to have the ability to raise a woman’s status but, simultaneously still view them as “other”.
Do I think that my roommates meant it this way? No, absolutely not. It is along the same idea that people who say, “you guys”, “mankind”, and “all men are created equal” do not mean to erase women, but that does not mean that’s not what’s happening. I know that they mean for it to be a term of endearment, but I cannot help being offended and after consistent exposure this semester to feminist rhetoric and ideas it is hard to ignore the screaming feminist that has developed inside of me.
Before my inner feminist could protest though, at the beginning, even when initially questioning it, I could not help being proud of the title. Like, “Yeah, I am one of the guys. I am cool.” I mean it is hard not to be happy when you feel included with a group, and I am happy that I’ve reached this level of friendship with guys who I think are good and genuine people. I can’t even lay the entire problem on them and males in general, because there is that spark of pride when I hear that I’m a “Bro”. I acknowledge that it plays into the competitiveness that is instilled in females under a patriarchal society. I admit I do feel better than other females, it’s a moment to boast that I am a Bro I’m part of the group, I have more authority than the other women. And the inner feminist screams and says I am playing into the hands of patriarchy, but I can’t help but wonder….is it okay to want to be both a “Bro” and a feminist?

I still think though, well shit, what if I do something girly like sharing my feelings, or anything else they deem “feminine”. Will I lose Bro status? Is it something I can keep regardless or can it be taken away? Will I quickly fall from grace and end up in the slop of the lesser, of woman? I get the feeling that this is a trial period, a thirty day money back guarantee, which at the end of it “Bro” status can be revoked and I go back to the being just “the roommate”. What makes it harder is that the inner feminist is getting louder and angrier over the b.s. that she sees within the patriarchal hegemonic ideology, and the ways that it plays itself out in society. I can’t help but have her anger be seen in my rolling of eyes, and outright proclamations of the unjustness of it all. Which makes me wonder; will my roommates not only take away “Bro” status, but label me instead with “Bitchy Feminist”? Will they censure themselves, not because I’ve changed their minds, but because they don’t want to hear my feminist perspective? Can I begin to expect nothing but eye rolls and snarky comments whenever I berate patriarchal society?
Unfortunately, I’m beginning to think that this just may be the life of a feminist living with college men. A constant internal struggle of asserting my beliefs and trying not to ostracize those around me.

I really enjoyed this post! It’s great that you relate an aspect of your everyday life to larger societal issues. Some may have simply brushed off “becoming a bro” in the eyes of their roommates, but your analysis shows that there can be embedded sexism (intentional or unintentional) in everyday events.
LikeLike
Thanks! Yeah, it’s one of those things that at first you don’t even realize what’s going on til you take a step back.
LikeLike
I love this post! I have a lot of guy friends too, and have often experienced the phenomenon of being a “bro” and all the double binds that come along with it. I think that being a “bro” also encourages women to partake in the “enlightened sexism” I talked about in my post on Monday – being a bro aligns women with the guys and gives them a sense of power, who cares if they are a little sexist? It’s EVERYWHERE in pop culture and in our every day lives, and hard to walk the line between being true to your feminist beliefs and being ostricized by male friends. I think the best thing to do is continuously (sometimes in sneaky ways) educate your friends – I want to believe that if your roomates knew the oppression women face and the history behind it that they would have a different attitude. I remember how much education on the subject changed my own views, and I think a major part of the problem is that men don’t even begin to realize how real, in your face, and bothersome sexism really is.
LikeLike
I’m glad you made mention of the fact that the guys don’t see it as demeaning–their intent is one of endearment and inclusion. Regardless of intent though, this innocent by-product of male privilege still stands. From personal experience, I’ve almost felt complimented when referred to as one of the guys, but it’s at the expense of forfeiting some measure of femininity, or at least temporarily suspending it. “Bro” is, in my mind, equivalent of getting “mad respect, dude”, or whatever. So, does that mean that if you’re not a bro, you’re just the kinda girl whose tail the boys want to chase after? Not worthy of that sort of friend/kinship association? I can’t emphasize enough, though, that I don’t think mine or your “bros” put any sort of thought into this, and I genuinely think this is a way of conveying their affection (alternatively, could you imagine your guy friends telling you that they just love how well you relate to them, and how you really touch and fulfill their emotional needs by your extensive knowledge of Call of Duty, Modern Warfare, BroBible, and the latest Coheed and Cambria album? Uhhh…). However, from a feminist perspective, I think it DOES have ramifications, even if the offenders mean well. You did an amazing job of conveying that sentiment. Your style and insights are just too cool.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Feminists of Westminster Unite and commented:
Wonder if becoming a ” Sis” have the same meanings…
LikeLike
Great question! I don’t believe it does, because I don’t think girls often label guys this way. Often I have found when they do they are typically talking about a guy who they believe to be/ or is gay. Which brings up a whole other set of issues in itself.
LikeLike